[This piece first appeared in the Hillsdale Collegian (3.31.2016)]
Corporate welfare is alive and well, even here in Hillsdale.
The Michigan Economic Development Corporation is the institution responsible for organizing and directing corporate welfare in the state of Michigan. According to their website, the MEDC offers “business assistance services and capital programs for business attraction and acceleration.” In practice, this amounts to allocating tax dollars as direct subsidies to businesses, often coupled with special tax breaks.
The MEDC recently funded two projects in Hillsdale. The first was an $82,865 subsidy to Mar-Vo Mineral Company to purchase the old FW Stock and Sons Mill (“Mar-Vo moves in, ‘breathes life’ into abandoned mill,” September 17, 2015). The second was the heftier $785,000 “community development block grant” for the purposes of renovating an old factory into apartments (“Former fur factory fitted for flats,” March 17, 2016).
Proponents trotted out familiar arguments to justify the taxpayer subsidy of private enterprise, noting that the projects would revitalize downtown Hillsdale, as well as create jobs and housing. While these are certainly benefits, the arguments ignore the costs. For one, similar arguments are made across the state to justify corporate welfare, resulting in almost $600 million doled out in “grants, programs, and projects” in 2015.
Organizations like the MEDC are an affront to the free market, and little more than a vehicle for crony capitalism. Unlike a private investor, the MEDC can only get funds through taxation. So taxpayers from across the state of Michigan, from Houghton to Detroit, are obligated to subsidize businesses to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars a year. Despite the gross injustice of being forced to subsidize projects that most receive no benefits from, corporate welfare persists. Why?
The answer is simple. Businesses and private individuals realize that, rather than trying to succeed or fail in the market, it is easier to get help from the state. Under the guise of “economic development,” or “jobs,” or “revitalization,” they can earn subsidies from the MEDC, and stick Michigan taxpayers with the bill. The benefits are concentrated to businesses and politically-connected individuals, while the costs are dispersed over millions of Michiganders.
Frederic Bastiat, a 19th-century French political economist, noted that economics involves looking at the seen and the unseen. In terms of corporate welfare, the seen effects are the projects they fund. New apartment buildings, bustling factories, and so on. The unseen is more complicated.
Think of what $600 million could have done in the hands of Michigan residents, rather than in the hands of government bureaucrats funneling the money to special interests. Private individuals, working in the free market, fund projects they think will be profitable, and decline those which seem likely to fail. In this system, businesses only profit by providing what the consumers want, and not by lobbying the government for subsidy. All of these potential opportunities are necessarily unseen, because they never came to be. Instead, taxpayers are stuck with a bill of almost a million dollars to build apartments in a small, out-of-the-way city in southern Michigan.
Students of Hillsdale College, an institution that stands for defending liberty, should oppose this great injustice. The MEDC is nothing more than dressed-up corporate welfare, existing to benefit special interests at the expense of the state as a whole, and the taxpayers that have to foot the bill.
"Reject all systems, and try liberty - liberty, which is an act of faith in God and in His work." - Frédéric Bastiat
Showing posts with label crony capitalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label crony capitalism. Show all posts
Saturday, April 23, 2016
Wednesday, August 5, 2015
The Economic Illiteracy of Bernie Sanders
Bernie Sanders, the feisty Independent Senator from Vermont, is challenging Hillary Clinton for the Democratic Presidential nomination. Originally seen as little more than a token resistance, Sanders has continually drawn crowds numbering in the thousands, and his fair share of media attention.
A Monmouth University Poll (August 5) shows that he is still well behind the frontrunner, Clinton, but comfortably ahead of the rest of the meager Democratic field.
From the beginning, Bernie Sanders' campaign has been about economic issues. He favors economic reforms such as a $15 per hour national minimum wage, an end to all free trade agreements, and economic redistribution (calling our current system "rigged"). For every one thing he gets right (such as his opposition to the Export-Import Bank), he gets five things dead wrong.
Sanders describes himself as a democratic socialist, and his campaign rhetoric revolves around not only the political establishment, but what he calls the oligarchy. The oligarchy is the power structure of big business and government that allegedly colludes to conspire against the average American. To an extent, he's right about the disease. Crony capitalism, government-private partnerships, or whatever other intrusions of the state into economic affairs there may be are indeed one of the biggest problems facing America today.
However, his cure is worse than the ailment. Sanders consistently advocates for MORE government intrusion into the market, not less. He wants more regulation, less freedom of trade, and less freedom of labor. While some of his proposed reforms may indeed weaken big business, he completely misses the point.
Commerical interests have a tendency to use the coercive apparatus of the government to restrict competition, increase their own market share, and lobby for regulations that benefit their own specific niche in the economy, rather than the market as a whole. Sanders sees this and decries big business. He glosses over the fact that the only reason business interests are able to do this is through the coercive apparatus of the government! The centralized, bureaurcratic, constantly growing government is the source of the problem.
In his quest to purge the country of inequality, Sanders also chooses the most ridiculous topics to attack. He has claimed that we have too many choices of deodorant and sneakers while children go hungry. He advocates for a minimum wage of $15 per hour while simultaneously pushing for full employment, and pays his interns less than his lofty minimum wage.
A Monmouth University Poll (August 5) shows that he is still well behind the frontrunner, Clinton, but comfortably ahead of the rest of the meager Democratic field.
Sanders is tapping into the anti-establishment sentiment sweeping across the nation, blaming "establishment politics" for the woes of the country. This outsider spirit, youth appeal, and distrust towards the status quo have caused some to dub him "the Ron Paul of the left". Indeed, many young left-libertarians are applauding his stances on money in politics and crony capitalism, and deservedly so. However, this only captures a small part of his campaign platform.
From the beginning, Bernie Sanders' campaign has been about economic issues. He favors economic reforms such as a $15 per hour national minimum wage, an end to all free trade agreements, and economic redistribution (calling our current system "rigged"). For every one thing he gets right (such as his opposition to the Export-Import Bank), he gets five things dead wrong.
Sanders describes himself as a democratic socialist, and his campaign rhetoric revolves around not only the political establishment, but what he calls the oligarchy. The oligarchy is the power structure of big business and government that allegedly colludes to conspire against the average American. To an extent, he's right about the disease. Crony capitalism, government-private partnerships, or whatever other intrusions of the state into economic affairs there may be are indeed one of the biggest problems facing America today.
However, his cure is worse than the ailment. Sanders consistently advocates for MORE government intrusion into the market, not less. He wants more regulation, less freedom of trade, and less freedom of labor. While some of his proposed reforms may indeed weaken big business, he completely misses the point.
Commerical interests have a tendency to use the coercive apparatus of the government to restrict competition, increase their own market share, and lobby for regulations that benefit their own specific niche in the economy, rather than the market as a whole. Sanders sees this and decries big business. He glosses over the fact that the only reason business interests are able to do this is through the coercive apparatus of the government! The centralized, bureaurcratic, constantly growing government is the source of the problem.
In his quest to purge the country of inequality, Sanders also chooses the most ridiculous topics to attack. He has claimed that we have too many choices of deodorant and sneakers while children go hungry. He advocates for a minimum wage of $15 per hour while simultaneously pushing for full employment, and pays his interns less than his lofty minimum wage.
Bernie Sanders has consistently displayed a massive economic illiteracy. Even with the few things he gets right, his abysmal economic policy prescriptions make him the absolute wrong choice for President.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
